What is wrong with Gilbert Grape? This question has intrigued audiences since the release of the film “Gilbert Grape” in 1993. Directed by Lasse Hallström and based on the novel by Steven Millhauser, the film tells the story of a young man named Gilbert Grape, who struggles with the challenges of life in a small town while taking care of his mentally challenged brother, Arnie. The film’s portrayal of Gilbert’s struggles raises questions about the societal expectations placed on individuals with disabilities and the burden of responsibility that falls on family members. This article aims to explore the various aspects of what is wrong with Gilbert Grape and how these issues reflect broader societal concerns.
The first and most apparent problem with Gilbert Grape is the societal pressure to conform to traditional gender roles. Gilbert, portrayed by Johnny Depp, is expected to be the breadwinner and provider for his family, despite his young age and the fact that he is still in high school. This expectation not only hinders his personal growth but also creates a sense of guilt and inadequacy when he is unable to fulfill these roles. The film highlights the unrealistic expectations placed on young men in small-town America, which can lead to feelings of isolation and frustration.
Another issue that plagues Gilbert Grape is the stigma associated with his brother, Arnie. Arnie, played by Leonardo DiCaprio, is depicted as a gentle and innocent individual who has Down syndrome. The film shows that despite his disability, Arnie is capable of love and friendship. However, the townspeople’s perception of him as a burden on the family and a source of shame leads to discrimination and isolation. This reflects the broader societal prejudice against individuals with disabilities, which can prevent them from fully participating in community life and enjoying the same rights and opportunities as others.
In addition to the societal pressures, Gilbert Grape also faces personal challenges. The film portrays his struggle with his own identity and his desire to break free from the confines of his small town. Gilbert’s relationship with his love interest, Courtney Pelt, played by Juliette Lewis, further complicates his life. Their relationship is hindered by the expectations of their families and the fear of what might happen if they were to leave the town. This struggle for freedom and independence is a common theme in coming-of-age stories, and Gilbert’s journey resonates with many viewers who have felt trapped by their circumstances.
Lastly, the film raises questions about the role of family in an individual’s life. Gilbert’s responsibility towards his brother Arnie is a heavy burden that he carries throughout the film. While his love for Arnie is evident, the film also explores the emotional toll of being the primary caregiver for someone with a disability. This highlights the challenges faced by families with disabled members and the need for support systems to help them cope with the difficulties they encounter.
In conclusion, what is wrong with Gilbert Grape is a multifaceted issue that encompasses societal expectations, discrimination against individuals with disabilities, personal struggles for identity and independence, and the emotional burden of family responsibilities. The film serves as a poignant reminder of the challenges faced by individuals in small-town America and the need for a more inclusive and supportive society.
