What is wrong with Elphaba? This question often arises among fans of the musical “Wicked” and those who have delved into the character’s complex backstory. Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West, is a character whose journey from innocence to malice is both fascinating and troubling. This article aims to explore the various aspects of Elphaba’s character and the issues that seem to be at the heart of her turmoil.
Elphaba’s story is one of injustice, oppression, and the struggle for identity. Born into a world that shuns her for her green skin, Elphaba faces discrimination and prejudice from a young age. This initial injustice sets the stage for her transformation into the Wicked Witch. However, it is not merely the external pressures that drive Elphaba to her dark fate; it is also her internal conflicts and the choices she makes along the way.
One of the most significant issues with Elphaba is the portrayal of her as a victim. While it is true that she faces numerous hardships, the musical often seems to suggest that her actions are solely a response to the injustice she has endured. This portrayal can be problematic, as it may imply that her descent into darkness is justified, or even inevitable, given her circumstances. However, this perspective overlooks the complexity of human nature and the responsibility individuals hold for their actions.
Moreover, Elphaba’s character is often seen as a symbol of resistance against an oppressive regime. While this is a powerful message, it can also lead to a one-dimensional portrayal of Elphaba. The musical sometimes seems to suggest that her only purpose is to fight against the system, which can undermine the depth of her character and the complexity of her motivations. Elphaba’s personal growth and the challenges she faces in her quest for self-acceptance are sometimes overshadowed by her role as a revolutionary figure.
Another issue with Elphaba’s character is the way in which her intelligence and power are portrayed. While her intellect is celebrated, her use of her magical abilities is often portrayed as a means to an end, rather than an intrinsic part of her identity. This can lead to a disconnect between Elphaba’s inner self and her external actions, making it difficult for audiences to fully understand her character.
Furthermore, the musical’s portrayal of Elphaba’s relationship with her nemesis, Glinda, raises questions about the nature of friendship and loyalty. While the two characters are often seen as polar opposites, their relationship is complex and multifaceted. However, the musical sometimes seems to suggest that Elphaba’s ultimate betrayal of Glinda is justified, which can be problematic, as it undermines the importance of trust and loyalty in relationships.
In conclusion, what is wrong with Elphaba is not necessarily her character flaws or her actions, but rather the way in which her story is told. The musical “Wicked” presents a complex and intriguing character, but it also risks oversimplifying her journey and the issues she faces. By exploring the nuances of Elphaba’s character and the challenges she encounters, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of human nature and the choices we make in the face of adversity.
